Written in collaboration with The Watch Exchange London

The world of luxury watches offers an intricate blend of craftsmanship, engineering, and history. For the budding horologist or the seasoned connoisseur, the choice between mechanical and quartz timepieces can be a defining decision. This comparison seeks to unravel the nuances, merits, and demerits of both.

1. Heritage and craftsmanship

Mechanical watches

Mechanical timepieces have a rich history spanning centuries. They are powered by an intricate arrangement of springs and gears. Winding the mainspring stores energy, and as it gradually unwinds, this energy drives the gear train, regulating the movement of the watch’s hands.

The artisanship, the handcrafted bridges, wheels, and springs all converge to offer a visual spectacle, especially in skeletonised models.

Quartz watches

Quartz watches, meanwhile, have a shorter, albeit revolutionary history, beginning in the late 1960s. These are battery-driven, with the battery sending an electrical signal through a piece of quartz crystal, which oscillates at a precise frequency. This oscillation regulates the motor to move the watch’s hands.

While there is beauty in its precision, quartz movements often don’t evoke the same romantic sentiment as their mechanical counterparts.

2. Accuracy and maintenance

Mechanical watches 

While there’s an undeniable charm in owning a timepiece that’s a manifestation of human engineering, mechanical watches generally don’t match quartz in terms of accuracy. They might gain or lose a few seconds or minutes over a month. Moreover, they require regular servicing, typically every 3-5 years, to ensure longevity and maintain accuracy.

Quartz watches 

When it comes to sheer precision, quartz watches are superior. They can remain accurate to within seconds over many months. Maintenance is also simpler: you’ll need a battery change roughly every 1-2 years and less frequent servicing than a mechanical watch.

3. Price and resale value

Mechanical watches

Mechanical timepieces, especially those from renowned brands, often command a higher price. The intricacies of their design, their legacy, and their meticulous craftsmanship make them sought-after pieces of art. Interestingly, specific models and brands of mechanical watches appreciate over time, making them potential investment pieces.

For instance, a visit to The Watch Exchange London would reveal an ever-changing collection of mechanical watches, each with its own story and potentially increasing in value.

Quartz watches 

How much is your watch worth

In the luxury segment, quartz watches are usually more accessible price-wise. However, their resale value doesn’t often match that of their mechanical peers. That said, some limited-edition quartz pieces or those from coveted collections can still hold significant value.

4. Environmental impact and sustainability

Mechanical watches 

Mechanical watches, with proper care, can last generations. Their longevity and the possibility of passing them down as heirlooms can be seen as sustainable, reducing the environmental footprint associated with producing new watches.

Quartz watches 

While quartz watches can also last a long time, their reliance on batteries presents an environmental challenge. Used batteries contribute to electronic waste. However, innovations like solar-powered quartz watches are making strides in offsetting these concerns.

5. Emotional resonance

Mechanical watches 

For many, the allure of mechanical watches lies in their heartbeat. Feeling the ticking on the wrist, hearing the soft movement of gears, and observing the ballet of its parts create an emotional connection. They are living entities, representative of a bygone era of artisanship.

Quartz watches 

Quartz watches might not offer the same visceral experience, but they stand as symbols of modernity, efficiency, and the triumph of human innovation. For those who appreciate precision, reliability, and a minimalist aesthetic, quartz watches can resonate deeply.

In conclusion

Choosing between mechanical and quartz in the luxury watch market is as much an emotional decision as it is a logical one. While the precision and practicality of quartz watches are undeniable, mechanical watches enchant with their rich history and artisanal beauty.

As with all things luxurious, it’s about personal preference and the unique story one wishes to wear on one’s wrist.

You may also like...